Looking for Fayetteville NC cheap car insurance with a low down payment? You found it!  Quality car insurance plus other auto insurance including truck insurance, motorcycle insurance, RV insurance, scooter insurance, SUV insurance, commercial truck insurance and commercial car insurance has been provided by our comparison agents for eight decades.  We research, you decide. Call us now to get the information you need. Desktop users can dial, mobile numbers can click to call this number (910) 323-8181. We are conveniently located at 815 Elm St., Eutaw Village North in Fayetteville, NC.


Over 80 years we’ve been recognized for service and we are happy to receive the 2023 Quality Business Award for local Auto Insurance in Fayetteville NC. This includes vehicles of all makes, models, shapes and sizes. Call now. Desktop users can dial, mobile numbers can click to call this number (910) 323-8181 and talk to manager Mildred todayl.

Best Car and Auto Insurance Fayetteville NC 

The professionals at Protective Agency have been providing residents, drivers, and businesses in our area with cheap car insurance, quality insurance coverage and exceptional financing options for 80+ years. Servicing all of North Carolina, Protective Agency employs experienced and licensed professionals to help you obtain good auto insurance in Fayetteville as well as business insurance to meet all your coverage needs.


Coverage Offered


Our experienced office staff members care very much about the coverage you or your business will need, including:

  • Auto Insurance: Whether your driving record is impeccable or tarnished, the licensed agents in Fayetteville will provide choices specific to your needs. Our agents will search for an affordable auto insurance in Fayetteville with the low monthly payments.
  • Motorcycle Insurance: With over a quarter million motorcycles registered in North Carolina, our professionals are here to meet your needs. Our motorcycle policies provide liability, property damage, collision, OTC and other optional coverage that allow us to design a policy to meet your needs and also fit within your budget.
  • Commercial Insurance: Our licensed agents in Fayetteville are no strangers to commercial vehicle insurance coverage. Whether you are a one-person contractor or a transportation business with a fleet of vehicles, we can design the a favorable and affordable commercial vehicle policy specific to your business needs.
  • Homeowner: Whether mortgaged or purchased in full, your home is likely to be your most valuable asset. The professionals at Protective Agency will design a veil of coverage around your home at an affordable rates with financing that will fit within your budget.
  • Renter’s Insurance: Whenever and wherever you rent, your landlord’s insurance will not protect you or your belongings if you are found liable for third-party injuries. Contact the experienced agents at Protective Agency for a free and confidential quote for renter’s insurance from a highly rated company at an affordable rate.


For a free and confidential quote for auto insurance in Fayetteville, we encourage our current and prospective customers to call the Fayetteville Office now.  Desktop users can dial, mobile numbers can click to call this number (910) 323-8181.


Service is Our Guarantee!


The insurance professionals at Protective Agency understand how important it is to provide exceptional service to all of our clients. We know that only exceptional service will result in long-term customer relationships, and to that end, exceptional service is our guarantee. With any type of insurance, changes can happen frequently; feel free to call our office to make changes to your auto insurance in Fayetteville or to make a payment on your account.


Claims Happen


The professionals at Protective Insurance Agency in Fayetteville and the companies we research understand that insurance is only a promise until a claim is filed. Whether it’s a fender bender or multi-car accident, we want to help you through the claims process and get you back on the road sooner than later. We are here to help our customers with medical expense claims and the costs of getting your vehicle repaired or replaced after an accident.


For great rates and insurance information, desktop users may call, mobile users can tap here (910) 323-8181. If you’re new to North Carolina or not sure of the location nearest you, visit a list of locations online at ProtectiveAgency.Com